The Sensible Environmentalist
(NAPS)�DEAR DR. MOORE: Does logging have a long
term impact on biodiversity?
When people think of biodiversity
they usually think of species
diversity, which refers to the different
animals, plants
and insects in a given
area. Harvesting,
especially when
most of the trees are
removed, has a considerable
impact on
species diversity but
only in the short
term.
Unless it�s converted for farmland
or development, almost any
forest will grow back to be as
beautiful and diverse as the one it
replaces. This has been demonstrated
through the ages by the
many forests around the world
that have regenerated after disturbance,
not only from logging
but from fire, ice, wind, volcanic
eruption and disease.
With or without human intervention,
forests are in a constant
state of change�and different
stages of forest growth appeal to
different species. After a disturbance
such as fire, a site will
attract grasses, berries and grazing
animals, which like open
areas. As the forest grows, species
come and go based on the environment
they prefer. In the case of
wildlife, this might include the
mature, low elevation forests
needed by deer and elk during
winter or old growth forests with
dead trees used
However, while a forest will
grow back on its own, there is a
link between sustainable forestry
and biodiversity. Sustainability is
governed by legislation and foresters
are required to show how
they will maintain habitat for a full
range of wildlife species. They also
have to ensure landscape diversity�
which refers to the different
types of ecosystem, such as wetlands
or old growth forests. An
important part of sustainable forest
management is designing harvest
patterns in such a way that forests
of all ages and all types of ecosystem,
are included on the landscape.
Some environmentalists promote
the idea that a forest cut is
an ecosystem gone forever but, in
fact, neither the biodiversity nor
the spiritual quality of the original
forest need be lost as the new
forest grows. I think that a sensible
environmentalist understands
that the process of renewal occurs
over many years and chooses to
see a recently harvested site for
what it is�a moment in time.